The criteria, in detail
These criteria retain the original research questions and dedicated routes. They do not establish that most services fail or that one marketing format is uniquely honest. Reference: method page
What the scorecard is actually sorting
Options evidence is contract-specific. These are functional product assessments, not audited performance rankings. VR remains an unranked model-record example because an options subscription and its contract coverage have not been confirmed. The framework is a document request list, not measured category-wide pass/fail data. Inspect an identified service and label missing evidence as unavailable.
| Object | Declared finding | Evidence boundary |
|---|---|---|
| Messaging | Original contract/leg versions and delivery | No presumed deleted losses |
| Copying | Source/follower contract and quantities | No automatic options mapping |
| Social event | Origin, chronology and stated inference | No assumed incentive model |
| Aggregator | Parent records and amendment links | Repetition is not separate validation |
| Automation | Frozen inputs, rule and account transitions | No assumed live performance |
| Claimed reviewed desk | Named reviewer, actual scope and full inventory | Audit label alone insufficient |
The formats below have different evidence objects. No single category is the only one outsiders can investigate. Original versions, account histories and frozen rule settings can support different bounded findings. Reference: pick
Why these two columns decide most cases
An options record needs the original contract terms and broker-side position evidence. A completed timestamp attests only to specified bytes by its block time. VR2 does not cover stop, target, option legs or a subscriber fill, so its presence cannot justify an options-service score.
The three tests with their own page
Sealed before the outcome
Why a public timestamp - with the grade hashed inside it - is the test a service cannot fake its way around.
A defined-risk structure
What a defined-risk call looks like, and why a bounded worst case is the first thing an options buyer should demand.
Grades that are measured
How an A-to-D conviction grade is calibrated to a model's own returns instead of a mood word.
Complete population and incentive records can require substantial work. They are not automatically easier to verify than chronology. Retain missing records and their actual source dates. Reference: method page
The map is a request inventory
An original alert needs contract and amendment records. An account-copying product needs source and follower routes. A rule platform needs frozen settings. A news tool needs source and event chronology. These are different request objects; no category receives a universal yes or no.
Fictional row: a news event has a documented originating timestamp but no option instructions. It is not a failed options-return record when it never claimed that job, and not a verified trading edge either. Match evidence to the actual selected function.
A completed format comparison
Fictional message source retains the first contract pair, amendment and actual receipt time but supplies no subscriber fill. The documented object is the instruction chronology. A separate fictional account source supplies fills but no parent publication record; execution is documented while original publication chronology remains unresolved. Neither format earns a universal yes in every column.
A reviewer can retain both findings with their source dates and population limits. Do not replace this evidence ledger with a tick because a service calls itself audited, or with a cross because it uses a messaging app. The underlying source objects, not the interface labels, determine the conclusion.